COVID-19 UPDATE: We are open! Our team is working and offering consultations via phone, e-mail, and video conferencing.
Available to Help 24/7

We also do home and hospital visits. All consultations are free!

  • Please enter your name.
  • This isn't a valid email address.
    Please enter your email address.
  • This isn't a valid phone number.
    Please enter your phone number.
    You entered an invalid number.
  • Please enter a message.
    Please select an option.
Aggressive. Trusted. Respected.

Negligent Security Claims

Santa Clarita Personal Injury Lawyer

In the past ten years, the case law on premises liability concerning negligent security has received special attention from the California Supreme Court. The current answer to the question of whether a property owner can be held liable for crimes that take place on his or her property in California is "yes, sometimes."

The circumstances under which a negligent security claim would be successful against the property owner are complicated and in order to ensure a positive outcome for the plaintiff, a skilled personal injury attorney should be brought on to argue the case.

In 1993, the California Supreme Court refined its test to determine a property owner's liability for criminal acts that take place on their property. The case law was established as "The Duty to Protect Against Criminal Act" in the case Ann M. v. Pacific Plaza Shopping Center, 6 Cal.4 th 666, after a female employee of a business was raped during working hours. The court established guidelines to be used in that case and in any given case that called for determining whether a business property owner could be held responsible for third party actions on his or her property.

Prior to this case, the court had operated off of the rule that totally of circumstances determined liability, without giving heed to foreseeability of the crime due to prior incidents. In Ann . M, the court refined the rule to consider the likelihood of criminal instances with how burdensome the proposed security measures would be to protect against that threat. It became a weighing mechanism to whether the property owner had the ability or the duty to protect against a certain instance.

Filing a Negligent Security Claim

While this protects commercial landlords from lawsuits that do not logically pertain to them, it has made litigation in this area substantially more complicated. When a criminal is prosecuted for an act of assault, the punishment they receive does little for the injured victim except give them peace of mind. Injuries from assault and rape can be detrimental to the victim emotionally, medically and financially. For this reason, civil action is a typical option for victims, either against the assailant or another liable party, such as the property owner.

In many instances of crime, the event could have been prevented with proper security measures such as camera systems, updated alarms and security personnel. Although the court has narrowed the scope under which a plaintiff may file against a commercial landlord, there are numerous legitimate claims of negligent security that can lead to substantial compensation for the victims.

Contact The Law Offices of Gerald L. Marcus

The key to a successful negligent security claim in California is to determine the legitimacy of the claim early on as to protect against dismissal and allow for enough preparation time.

If you were made victim to a violent crime in Santa Clarita, you should contact a Santa Clarita personal injury attorney right away.

Even if the criminal prosecution against your assailant is ongoing, you can explore your options for filing a negligent security claim against the property owner and the sooner you start the process, the better your chances are for a successful claim.

A Santa Clarita personal injury lawyer at The Law Offices of Gerald L. Marcus will be able to examine the circumstances of your case and determine whether you have grounds for a negligent security claim. Furthermore, our attorneys will guide you through the entire process and use their experience in this area to bring about a positive outcome for you.

For more information about filing a successful negligent security claim in Santa Clarita, contact The Law Offices of Gerald L. Marcus to speak with a member of our legal team today.

The Preferred Choice Since 1987
See What Our Clients Have to Say

  • “Thank you so much for your experience, expertise, kindness and patience”

    Debbie R

  • “Thank you for the compassion & great professional service that I received from your office. If the need arises I will refer anyone who needs representation to your office. Sincerely”

    Linda S. Barrett

  • “I am very grateful to you for your kindness. And I want you to know that I gratefully appreciate it with all my heart.”


  • “Thank you for accepting this case and for your pleasant and prompt handling of it.”


  • “I especially liked the fact that my case was not taken lightly, and every detail was thought out by you, and I didn’t have to initiate anything on my end, as you had taken care of even the tiniest of details.”

    Brandi C. Creason

Choose a Trusted & Respected Firm

  • Over 30 Years of Legal Experience

  • More Than $125 Million Recovered for Clients

  • Winners of the 2017 Best Law Firm of America Award

  • All Cases Accepted On a Contingency Fee Basis

  • Large Support Staff, Including Private & Field Investigators

  • Aggressive, Prompt, & Personal Attention for Clients

  • Solely Devoted to People - Not Businesses or Companies